Lost Video Island

MariaPurt · Expert Vidder Joined: 14 Sep 2009 Posts: 631

***Automated Message***
"Shattered (Kate / Juliet)" 11-02-2009
This is my part of the first lostobsessedstudios1 Collab video ;D
Song: Shatteredo by ---
Vidder: MariaPurt
Length: 0:26 (9,3 mb wmv)

Link(s): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=enT9nWGIX1s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=enT9nWGIX1s

MariaPurt · Expert Vidder Joined: 14 Sep 2009 Posts: 631

Not sure where to post this link, so i'll put it here. The full colab video is done (all made of Lost), and thus it's here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sbr_zu3R2RM

SassyLostie2

Nice job, it was very pretty.

I'm wondering why everyone voted you silver though? Just because it was short? It was supposed to be, it was an MEP part! The editing in the 26 seconds was very good, it was gold worthy, so I don't see why it should get that. If we were still on the points system, these silvers would have seriously brought your average down. That's not very fair. :S But oh well, I thought it was a good job on your part. I'm going to go watch the whole video now.

MariaPurt · Expert Vidder Joined: 14 Sep 2009 Posts: 631

Well, since all the silve VP are hidden, i suggest personal vendetta for me giving people silver ones LOL Or maybe someone really didn't read the description as to why it was so short... what can i say, i suppose if people has smth about this vid, they'd say it LOL
Stll, thanks for your support! (Maybe people just don't like Kuliet? Huh?)

Aislynn · Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 9:02 pm Post subject:

Very pretty vid! However, I had to take a few days to decide how I was going to vote on it (since you asked for my reason behind my vote, I'll give it

). It is very short but not much shorter than a trailer, so that in and of itself wasn't a problem for me.

I did understand that this is part of a collab vid but since you submitted this on its own, all I could do was vote on this, just what was submitted, not for what this might look like as part of the collab vid.

I put a great deal of thought and deliberation into this, even more than I normally do, because of all of the unusual factors this vid presented.

When I weighed everything up, the technical skills were Gold-level but the story and the entire flow of the vid cuts off before it can go anywhere.

And yes, I do understand why it does that, it's just a piece of the puzzle, a couple of seconds snipped out of a bigger vid. But again, I'm not voting on the entire vid or what this part might look like with the rest of the story around it, I'm voting on just this. And so it's a very pretty 26 seconds that builds up and then cuts off abruptly and that is basically what made it a high-end Silver vid to me.

littleton_pace · Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2009 5:16 am Post subject:

Ooh; im glad you posted a link to the finished product

That was really great ;P Your part is really awesome and I love that song so much! I dont think I'll ever get sick of seeing vids to it

Plus, you vidded Kuliet so I was bound to love it, and I doubt that's why people tuned out! They're awesome!

I know you like people to post good feedback behind their vote as well

So I have to agree with Ais tho, since the vote goes to only this piece of the video, you don't get the effect of the full thing, so that's why I voted Silver. I personally don't see the point in posting just a small section of a whole video, but that's just me. I do kinda hope you extend your little piece because I really was into seeing a full Kuliet vid to this song lol ;P

btw, meaning to ask, how crushed are you about Dollhouse? I've never even seen it and I was sad!

_________________

MariaPurt · Expert Vidder Joined: 14 Sep 2009 Posts: 631

Well, kitties, first of all thanks! All i have to say now is that if you did make your VPs not hidden, and i saw those were yours, i would kbow soething was really wrong about the vid. Now, as to posting a short piece, well, since i really don't feel like vidding this song, and i thought the idea of my part was clear, well, maybe i just liked this short vidlet too much to simply ignore it (and if i did, i wouldn't have a place to put the link to the full video LOL). I'm doing several colabs, and my parts either go to Heroes or Lost (so beware, some more short pieces might be comming hehe).

Maybe i'll take this colab part and make a ful vid of it with another song - when i'm totally outta ideas (which is not happenening any soon since i have V show to vid LOL).

As to the Dollhouse, i totally love it (even thou i've no idea why i can't get anything after ep 4 of the 2nd season - it either didn't air or i can't find it - who knows). Some say they don't like the show where the main character personality doesn't develop - wrong. Echo's mind is MIND and not emptiness. The show is light/bright/colorful and totally anti-depressing ;D
_________________

Uruviel

Great vid! It's very pretty & edited well, but I voted silver (I usually leave all my votes hidden, whether gold, silver, etc), because it is not a finished video. I did read the description, & I agree with Ais & Kat, I had to base my vote on the part that was submitted. It took me a while to decide how to vote, but the way the ending just cut off is mostly what determined my vote.

Wow, just watched the finished video, it's excellent!

MariaPurt · Expert Vidder Joined: 14 Sep 2009 Posts: 631

We're starting a new Lost colab vid soon, so i guess i shouldn't post any of my pieces again, right?
_________________