Lost Video Island

[LVI Bot]

"Good n Evil" 06-17-2006
If the Others are the good ones then maybe being bad is better
Song: Good n Evil by Linda Eder
Vidder: luvforsawyer
Length: 3:30 (40.8 MB WMV)

Link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wwt5Xe8Ubbc

[luvforsawyer]

Please let me know what you guys think of this (good or bad). Any and all feedback is very appeciated!
_________________
Read and review my fanfics (LOST and Rent) at: http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1061227/

[thefilmchick]

Good setting of atmosphere at the beginning, and generally a fairly even tone throughout the piece; I don't ever get the feeling that the music is discordant with the clips.

However, there are a few too many choppy cuts, and the rectangular-to-square switches are a bit jarring. Additionally, certain shots are too quick for the song - Sayid punching Henry when 'eeeeevil' is the line is jarring.

There's a nice switch between evil and good in there - I get and like the sarcasm of the shots.

Generally, there are a few too many talky shots.

The song has a lot of sonic "punches" to it that could be capitalized on with flashier shots where the music or the vocals snap.

That said, you did well on the build-up to the ending and once the music picked up and, like I said, I like the sarcasm behind making the 'good' shots cued to the Others and the 'evil' shots generally cued more to the Losties.
_________________
I saw a werewolf drinking a pina colada at Trader Vic's. His hair was perfect.

[luvforsawyer]

Thanks filmchick! This is the kind of feedback is really helpful for me. I hadn't done an action vid before so I really didn't have a clue what I was doing (lol). That being said, thanks for the tips on improvement.
_________________
Read and review my fanfics (LOST and Rent) at: http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1061227/

[Lost Freak 4815]

Good video! Kind of confused me, though. The lyrics kept making it seem like good was bad and evil was good. I still liked it.

[luvforsawyer]

Sorry for the confusion.....the lyrics of the song actually talk about if "good" people are corrupt and do "evil" things, then that should mean "evil" people are actually good. I just kind of tried to play around with that idea and the Others claiming to be good. Sorry if it just came out confusing, but I'm glad you liked it!
_________________
Read and review my fanfics (LOST and Rent) at: http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1061227/